Ex Parte Singer et al - Page 3


                    Appeal 2006-2836                                                                                                        
                    Application 09/923,673                                                                                                  

                                                               OPINION                                                                      
                            We affirm the aforementioned rejections.                                                                        
                            The Appellants state that the claims stand or fall together (Br. 6).                                            
                    Even though an additional reference is applied to some of the dependent                                                 
                    claims, the Appellants do not argue the separate patentability of those claims                                          
                    (Br. 11-12).  We therefore limit our discussion to one claim, i.e., claim 1.                                            
                    See 37 C.F.R. § 41.37(c)(1)(vii)(2004).                                                                                 
                            Gatley states that there would be considerable attraction to slot                                               
                    machine players if a slot machine (which Gatley calls a fruit machine)                                                  
                    provides a choice of games in one machine cabinet (p. 1, ll. 32-34).  Gatley’s                                          
                    slot machine “comprises a machine cabinet carrying on one side thereof two                                              
                    game display units adapted to display first and second independently                                                    
                    playable fruit machine games” (p. 2, ll. 5-8).  A player can play two games                                             
                    simultaneously on one machine (p. 3, ll. 8-17).  “The machine may have a                                                
                    common or independent controller for implementing the two machine                                                       
                    games” (p. 3, ll. 1-2).  “A common credit register may be provided, the                                                 
                    arrangement being such that credits on the register may be utilised by the                                              
                    player to play either game.  Similarly, a common credit register may be                                                 
                    provided to record winnings not yet taken, the winnings resulting from                                                  
                    games played on either game module” (p. 2, ll. 32-36).                                                                  
                            Piechowiak discloses a slot machine having multiple paylines (col. 9,                                           
                    ll. 13-25).                                                                                                             
                            Itkis discloses a distributed game network comprising a master game                                             
                    device used by a game operator and a number of slave game devices used by                                               
                    players (col. 1, ll. 41-43; col. 2, ll. 63-65).  “The master and slave game                                             

                                                                     3                                                                      

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013