Ex Parte Chasan et al - Page 5


              Appeal 2007-0691                                                                     
              Application 10/465,423                                                               
          1   [American Petroleum Institute] categories CF-4 and CG-4 by ASTM D 5968               
          2   and 120 ppm for category CH-4 by ASTM D 6594 [¶ 0006].                               
          3         Various components of formulated engine oils cause lead corrosion              
          4   [¶ 0007].                                                                            
          5         For example, desired additive chemistries that are aggressive towards          
          6   lead and are otherwise disqualified from use in engine oils include sulfur-          
          7   containing additives [¶¶ 0008 and 0132].                                             
          8         The engine oils useful in the invention include diesel and universal           
          9   oils [¶ 0011].                                                                       
         10         Universal oils encompass both diesel oils and passenger car oils               
         11   [¶ 0011].                                                                            
         12         The engine oils are employed in internal combustion engines, for               
         13   example, in motor vehicles fitted with engines of the Otto, Diesel, two-             
         14   stroke Wankel or orbital type [¶ 0011].                                              
         15         The engine oils comprise (a) a base fluid [¶ 0014], (b) a triazole             
         16   [¶ 0015] and (3) an additive that is aggressive towards lead [¶ 0017].               
         17         A suitable triazole is 1-(di-(2-ethylhexyl)aminomethyl)-1,2,4-triazole.        
         18         Example 1 in the specification is said to show the advantages of the           
         19   invention [¶¶ 0144 and 0145].                                                        
         20         For the purpose of deciding the appeal, we will assume that the                
         21   procedure in Example 1 was actually carried out and that the results reported        
         22   were actually obtained.                                                              
         23         A "fully formulated non-corrosive engine oil" is used as the base              
         24   formulation, to which is added 1.0 weight % glycerol monooleate (GMO) or             



                                                5                                                  

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013