Arkansas Code § 26-18-406 - Judicial Relief. [Effective Until October 1, 2015.)

(a) After the issuance and service on the taxpayer of the final assessment of a deficiency in tax that is not protested by the taxpayer under § 26-18-403 or a final determination of the hearing officer or the director under § 26-18-405, a taxpayer may seek judicial relief from the final determination or assessment by:

(1) (A) Paying the entire amount of state tax due for any taxable period or periods covered by the final assessment within one (1) year of the date of the final assessment and filing suit to recover that amount within one (1) year of the date of payment.

(B) The director may proceed with collection activities including the filing of a certificate of indebtedness as authorized under § 26-18-701 within thirty (30) days of the issuance of the final assessment for any assessed but unpaid state taxes, penalties, or interest owed by the taxpayer for other taxable periods covered by the final assessment while the suit for refund is being pursued by the taxpayer for other taxable periods covered by the final assessment;

(2) (A) Filing with the director a bond in double the amount of the tax deficiency due within thirty (30) days of the issuance and service on the taxpayer of the final assessment and by filing suit within thirty (30) days thereafter to stay the effect of the director's determination.

(B) The bond shall be subject to the conditions that the taxpayer shall:

(i) File suit within thirty (30) days after filing the bond;

(ii) Faithfully and diligently prosecute the suit to a final determination; and

(iii) Pay any deficiency found by the court to be due and pay any court cost assessed against him or her.

(C) A taxpayer's failure to file suit, diligently prosecute the suit, or pay any tax deficiency and court costs, as required by subdivision (a)(2)(B) of this section, shall result in the forfeiture of the bond in the amount of the assessment and assessed court costs; or

(3) Filing suit to recover assessed tax, penalty, and interest paid prior to the time for issuance of the final assessment within one (1) year of the date of the final determination of the hearing officer or the director under § 26-18-405.

(b) A taxpayer may seek judicial relief from a final determination denying a claim for refund by filing suit to recover the amount claimed within one (1) year from the mailing of the denial of the director under § 26-18-507, or a final determination of the hearing officer or the director under § 26-18-405, whichever is later.

(c) (1) Jurisdiction for a suit to contest a determination of the director under this section shall be in the Pulaski County Circuit Court or the circuit court of the county in which the taxpayer resides or has his or her principal place of business, where the matter shall be tried de novo.

(2) An appeal will lie from the circuit court to the Supreme Court, as in other cases provided by law.

(3) A presumption of correctness or weight of authority will not attach to a determination of the director in a trial de novo or an appeal under this section.

(d) (1) The methods provided in this section shall be the sole alternative methods for seeking relief from a written decision of the director establishing a deficiency in tax or disallowing a claim for refund.

(2) No injunction shall issue to stay proceedings for assessment or collection of any taxes levied under any state tax law.

(e) (1) In any court proceeding under this section, the:

(A) Prevailing party may be awarded a judgment for court costs; and

(B) Taxpayer may be awarded reasonable attorney's fees if the:

(i) Director revised a decision of the hearing officer in favor of the taxpayer under § 26-18-405;

(ii) Taxpayer is the prevailing party in an action for judicial relief from the determination of the director under this section; and

(iii) Court finds that the director's revision was without a reasonable basis in law and fact.

(2) A judgment of court costs entered by the court in favor of either party or of attorney's fees awarded in favor of the taxpayer shall be treated, for purposes of this chapter, in the same manner as an overpayment or deficiency of tax, except that interest or penalty shall not be allowed or assessed with respect to any judgment for court costs.

(f) If a taxpayer pays the tax, penalty, and interest assessed under § 26-18-403 and does not request administrative relief according to § 26-18-404, then:

(1) The taxpayer may seek judicial relief from the assessment only if the taxpayer files suit in circuit court within one (1) year from the date of payment of the assessment; and

(2) The provisions of § 26-18-507 shall not apply to the payments.

§ 26-18-406 - Judicial relief. [Effective October 1, 2015.]

(a) After the issuance and service on the taxpayer of the final assessment of a deficiency in tax that is not protested by the taxpayer under § 26-18-403 or a final determination of the hearing officer or the director under § 26-18-405, a taxpayer may seek judicial relief from the final assessment or determination by:

(1) (A) Filing suit for judicial relief from the final assessment or determination within one hundred eighty (180) days of the date of the final assessment or determination.

(B) A taxpayer filing suit under this subdivision (a)(1) shall not be required to pay the state tax, penalties, and interest due before filing suit;

(2) Paying the entire amount of state tax due within one (1) year of the date of the final assessment or determination and filing suit to recover that amount within one (1) year of the date of payment; or

(3) Filing suit to recover assessed tax, penalty, and interest paid prior to the time for issuance of the final assessment within one (1) year of the date of the final determination of the hearing officer or the director under § 26-18-405.

(b) A taxpayer may seek judicial relief from a final determination denying a claim for refund by filing suit to recover the amount claimed within one (1) year from the mailing of the denial of the director under § 26-18-507, or a final determination of the hearing officer or the director under § 26-18-405, whichever is later.

(c) (1) Jurisdiction for a suit to contest a final assessment or determination of the director under this section shall be in the Pulaski County Circuit Court or the circuit court of the county in which the taxpayer resides or has his or her principal place of business, where the matter shall be tried de novo.

(2) An appeal will lie from the circuit court to the Supreme Court, as in other cases provided by law.

(3) A presumption of correctness or weight of authority shall not attach to a final assessment or determination of the director in a trial de novo or an appeal under this section.

(d) (1) The methods provided in this section shall be the sole alternative methods for seeking relief from a written decision of the director establishing a deficiency in tax or disallowing a claim for refund.

(2) An injunction shall not issue to stay proceedings for assessment or collection of taxes levied under state tax law.

(e) (1) In a court proceeding under this section, the:

(A) Prevailing party may be awarded a judgment for court costs; and

(B) Taxpayer may be awarded reasonable attorney's fees if the:

(i) Director revised a decision of the hearing officer in favor of the taxpayer under § 26-18-405;

(ii) Taxpayer is the prevailing party in an action for judicial relief from the determination of the director under this section; and

(iii) Court finds that the director's revision was without a reasonable basis in law and fact.

(2) A judgment of court costs entered by the court in favor of either party or of attorney's fees awarded in favor of the taxpayer shall be treated, for purposes of this chapter, in the same manner as an overpayment or deficiency of tax, except that interest or penalty shall not be allowed or assessed with respect to a judgment for court costs or attorney's fees.

(f) If a taxpayer pays the tax, penalty, and interest assessed under § 26-18-403 and does not request administrative relief according to § 26-18-404, then:

(1) The taxpayer may seek judicial relief from the assessment only if the taxpayer files suit in circuit court within one (1) year from the date of payment of the assessment; and

(2) The provisions of § 26-18-507 shall not apply to the payments.

(g) The Arkansas Rules of Civil Procedure and § 16-56-126 concerning nonsuit and commencement of new actions apply to appeals under this section.

Section: Previous  26-18-402  26-18-403  26-18-404  26-18-405  26-18-406  

Last modified: November 15, 2016