Ex parte NGUYEN et al. - Page 6




          Appeal No. 95-0916                                                          
          Application 07/803,530                                                      


          appellants’ specification makes it clear that the baffle                    
          enclosure is a tube 100 having apertures 110 which directs the              
          flow of gas to a particular location and in a particular                    
          direction, and is something in addition to the various screens              
          (see, e.g., pages 6 and 7).  We can think of no circumstances               
          under which the artisan, consistent with the appellants’                    
          specification, would consider the filter layers 44, 52, 54, 50              
          and 56 of Goetz and the filter layers 11 and 13’ of Jorgensen               
          to be “baffle enclosures” as the examiner contends.  In Goetz               
          there is nothing which can be fairly considered to be a baffle              
          enclosure and in Jorgensen the member 12’ is the baffle                     
          enclosure.                                                                  
              Turning to the proposed combination of references, we                   
          observe that Goetz and Jorgensen are directed to two different              
          types of gas generators.  That is, the gas generator of Goetz               
          is designed for “cylindrical radial flow” (column 1, line 42)               
          of gas through all the screens, including screen 48 which the               
          examiner considers                                                          


          to be a cooling screen.  On the other hand, the gas generator               
          of Jorgensen is designed for circumferential flow of gas                    
                                          6                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007