Ex parte HAMMER et al. - Page 2




          Appeal No. 95-1167                                                            
          Application 07/928,027                                                        


          our consideration the final rejection of claims 1, 2, and 4 to                
          19, all the claims now remaining in the application.                          
               The subject matter on appeal is directed to a cellulose-                 
          based tubular foodstuff casing which has a coating comprising                 
          chitosan on its inner and/or outer surface wherein the chitosan               
          is chemically linked to the cellulose in the casing.                          
               Appellants separately argue each claim.  Claim 1 is the only             
          independent claim and reads as follows:                                       
               1.  A cellulose-based tubular foodstuffs casing having inner             
          and outer surfaces, said casing comprising a coating on said                  
          inner surface, on said outer surface, or on said inner and said               
          outer surfaces, wherein                                                       
               said coating comprises chitosan chemically linked to                     
          celluose present in said casing, and                                          
               wherein said cellulose has been prepared from a viscose                  
          solution by coagulation and regeneration.                                     

               The references relied upon by the Examiner are:                          
          Rose et al. (Rose)             3,427,169            Feb. 11, 1969             
          O'Brien et al. (O’Brien)       3,645,760            Feb. 29, 1972             
          Kosugi et al. (Kosugi)         4,378,017            Mar. 29, 1983             
          Godo et al.  (Godo)2                                                                  
          (Japanese)           174,699                        Jul. 11, 1989             




               The PTO translation of this Japanese laid open application indicates2                                                                       
          that the inventive entity is Godo et al. and not Taguchi et al.               
                                           2                                            





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007