Ex parte CRAIG R. MORGAN - Page 5




          Appeal No.95-5026                                                           
          Application 07/923,668                                                      



          is identified.  We note that Appellants' claim 1 recites these              
          means while Appellants' claim 13 recites method steps that                  
          perform these functions.   Appellants further emphasize in the              
          reply brief that Foley and Einkauf, either individually or                  
          together, fail to teach the Appellants' invention which relates             
          to the reduction of redundant matrix transformations of shared              
          polygonal vertex data as recited in Appellants’ claims.                     
               Einkauf teaches in column 1, lines 5-16, that their                    
          invention relates in general to a method for determining the                
          intensity and color parameters used to render shaded patterns on            
          a video display.  In column 2, lines 39-45, Einkauf teaches a               
          particularized implementation of their invention that involves              
          the use of triangular polygon regions.  This particularized                 
          implementation is further disclosed in column 4, line 6, through            
          column 5, line 31.  There Einkauf discloses that the triangular             
          polygon is divided into a mesh of triangles and then the cross              
          product of the values relating to each vertex of the triangle is            
          calculated.  However, Einkauf fails to teach a means for                    
          identifying a shared vertex or a means for retrieving stored                
          world space data corresponding to said shared vertex and                    
          supplying the retrieved world space data corresponding to said              

                                          5                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007