Ex parte SCHMIDT - Page 6




          Appeal No. 97-0894                                                          
          Application 08/069,931                                                      


          to function as mounting means.  Finally, as to dependent claim 4,           
          the teachings in Anderson indicate that the thermoplastic                   
          binder/resin is a polyamide resin filled with a magnetizable                
          material as indicated at column 4, lines 18 to 20.                          
               Both independent claims 1 and 7 contain the open-ended term            
          “comprising” at the end of the preamble which clearly indicates             
          that other elements than those recited in the body of the claim             
          may be encompassed within the teachings of the references relied            
          upon by the examiner.  The “included” and “consisting of”                   
          language of independent claims 1 and 7 on appeal are met by the             
          reasoning advanced by the examiner, as embellished above.                   
               From the collective teachings of the references it may be              
          seen that each of them function passively, in a non-contact                 
          manner, and contain overlapping, common teachings of measurement            
          devices which produce an electric current output as a measurement           
          signal.  Each of them also in some manner teaches some form of              
          coil bobbin/body of single-piece construction to which is                   
          attached a coil for achieving this measurement purpose associated           
          with magnetic principles.  Tomczak does not specifically teach,             
          but clearly suggests that the bobbin 52 in this reference may be            
          made by injection molding.  This feature is, however,                       
          specifically taught in Anderson and would have been clearly                 

                                          6                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007