Ex parte MILLIKEN et al. - Page 6




          Appeal No. 95-3498                                                           
          Application 08/176,330                                                       


          I/O boards for any type of peripheral device can be connected                
          into these slots.                                                            
               We agree that Shah does not expressly teach that these                  
          I/O boards contain only one of the type of I/O circuit (a                    
          digital input circuit, a digital output circuit, an analog                   
          input circuit and an analog output circuit).  However, Shah                  
          does suggest that the Shah system can connect any type of I/O                
          board for a partic-ular type peripheral device.  We note that                
          there are many particular types of peripheral device that                    
          would require only one type of I/O circuit.  For instance,                   
          audio speakers are a well- known peripheral device that only                 
          require an analog output circuit and LED displays are another                
          well-known peripheral device that only require a digital                     
          output circuit.  A temperature probe is a well-known                         
          peripheral device that only requires an analog input circuit                 
          or a digital input circuit depending upon the type of probe.                 
          Thus, we find that Shah would have suggested to those                        
          skilled in the art to provide a I/O board to be connected into               
          one of the identical slots 20 that would only have a single                  




                                          6                                            





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007