Ex parte STEWART et al. - Page 5




               Appeal No. 96-0258                                                                                                    
               Application 08/094,651                                                                                                


                   logical addresses to real addresses does not, necessarily, lead to a teaching of providing                        
                   the “offset information” claimed.  We agree with appellants [page 13 of the brief] that                           
                   claim 13 does not merely provide cross reference between the virtual to physical                                  
                   information but, rather, it recites “providing a page table prototype mechanism including                         
                   known cross-reference information… comprising offset information… ”  We find no such                              
                   teaching or suggestion in Sawada.  The claimed offset information is used to derive                               
                   physical address information from virtual address information.  There is nothing in Sawada                        
                   to suggest that the type of “aid” offered by the table look-up is offset information used to                      
                   derive a physical address from a virtual address.  The table look-up mechanism 12 of                              
                   Sawada does not even appear, from Figure 3, to receive  physical address information,                             
                   receiving, instead, the output of comparison circuit 5 which  receives, in part, information                      
                   from the logical, or virtual, address register 1.  Therefore, it is difficult to see how Sawada                   
                   can be said to suggest the provision of a page table prototype mechanism including known                          
                   cross-reference information comprising offset information between certain ones of the                             
                   virtual addresses and their corresponding physical addresses, as claimed.                                         










                                                                 5                                                                   





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007