Ex parte JENKIN et al. - Page 7




          Appeal No. 96-1200                                                            
          Application 08/011,453                                                        

          can broadly be considered a "processor means" at this point in                
          the claim.  In particular, there is no recitation that the                    
          processor "computes" anything.  The term "separately                          
          controllable" is not defined and is broadly met by the fact                   
          that the video drivers operate independently.                                 
               Appellants argue that "the function of the video drivers                 
          24A-24D [in Caine] is simply to read data from memories                       
          22A-22D which all receive data from the same source (Host                     
          Computer 10) and pass the sampled data to a display                           
          screen" (Br9).  This is true, but appellants do not state what                
          language of the claim requires the "processor means" to do                    
          more.                                                                         
               Claim 1 further recites "each processor means further                    
          including a first input connected to the network for receiving                
          network communication and a second input connected to at least                
          one touch sensitive screen for receiving input command signals                
          corresponding to the user touch input."  Again, no function is                
          recited for the "processor means" that would define over the                  
          video driver of Caine.  Two inputs are recited.  The input to                 
          the video drivers from buses 44 in Caine are inputs "for                      
          receiving network communication."  However, we disagree with                  

                                         - 7 -                                          





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007