Ex parte ANDERSON et al. - Page 7




          Appeal No. 96-1445                                                          
          Application 08/371,684                                                      


          whereas Hirsch’s approach disfavored the use of television                  
          type signals through a CRT device, Collender’s device permits               
          such a signal and type of information to be conveyed in a                   
          three dimensional environment.                                              
               The details of the CCDLCLV element discussed have been                 
          known in the prior art beginning at col. 7, line 26 of                      
          Collender.  Indeed, this portion, at lines 60 through 63,                   
          makes a specific cross reference to Ernstoff, another                       
          reference relied upon by the examiner in this rejection, by                 
          patent number to provide a color capability to the liquid                   
          crystal matrix array described in that reference.  Col. 8,                  
          lines 8 through 12 also indicate that other solid state                     
          imaging surfaces may be used to produce image arrays either by              
          reflective or transmissive means indicating that the liquid                 
          crystal approach was merely cited as one of those means.  To                
          the artisan, this logically leads to Hornbeck’s teachings.                  
               As to Ernstoff, it appears that each picture element                   
          forming an entire planar color image is formed by three                     
          primary color components using band reflective mirrors such as              
          dichroic mirrors in the back of the liquid crystal materials                
          forming the planar matrix array.  Each color "cell" in this                 
                                          7                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007