Ex parte LUEDERS - Page 8




          Appeal No. 96-3624                                                          
          Application No. 08/293,104                                                  


          clearly fails to suggest any such display membrane, Hunter                  
          providing a separate dedicated display for each definable                   
          function key.  Thus, the only reference left which could                    
          possibly disclose a display membrane is Koike.  But Koike                   
          discloses a transparent sheet 5 through which to view indicia,              
          an indicia sheet 6 which provides groups of indicia, some of                
          which will be masked and some of which will be visible,                     
          elastic members 3 and a rigid board 2 on which key contacts 1               
          are located.  The best that could be considered an overlay                  
          display membrane in Koike is the indicia sheet 6.  Yet, Koike               
          discloses nothing which may be considered the claimed                       
          programmable display membrane which is interactive with the                 
          keyboard such that display elements to be illuminated are                   
          addressed and a processor connected to both the keyboard and                
          the membrane causes the display, on the membrane, of                        
          positional and functional indicia.  Neither Hunter nor                      
          Polaroid is of any help in this regard since only Hunter shows              
          an interaction between definable function keys F1-F5 and                    
          dedicated displays 31-35 but clearly fails to suggest anything              
          like the claimed programmable template display membrane, which              
          covers the keyboard switches and interacts with the keyboard                
                                          8                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007