Ex parte HONG - Page 13



          Appeal No. 96-3999                                        Page 13           
          Application No. 08/395,719                                                  


               skirt 62 fits loosely over wall 32 of the spill chamber [so            
               that] the gas may flow out of the container and no pressure            
               build up is created.  In this fashion the container may be             
               incubated so as to stimulate the growth of the                         
               microorganisms.                                                        

               Westgate discloses a condiment container which is shaped so            
          as to permit easy stacking of condiment containers on one                   
          another.  The condiment container includes, inter alia, a glass             
          or clear plastic jar 10, a fitment 15 and a cap 45.  The cap 45             
          may be threaded and is provided with an annular ridge 46.  The              
          fitment 15 is provided with sifting holes 20.  The jar 10 has a             
          neck 11 provided with an external thread 13 and a recess 47                 
          provided in the bottom of the jar.  The recess 47 and ridge 46              
          aid in the stacking of the jars so that one jar can be mounted on           
          top of another.                                                             


               The examiner determined (answer, p. 5) that                            
               [i]t would have been obvious to add a threaded cap                     
               connection to Pepicelli's container to provide for a more              
               tightly secured cap which has to be opened by twisting                 
               rather than a mere pull in the vertical direction.                     

               The appellant argues (brief, p. 9) that                                
               merely because Westgate has a threaded cap would in no way             
               serve to make Pepicelli in any way suggestive of the                   
               dissimilar container of the present invention.                         









Page:  Previous  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007