Appeal No. 97-1151 Application 08/380,824 As is evident from our review of the Avery document, supra, this patent clearly fails to provide a rotatable receptacle with at least one of first and second projections being movable relative to the receptacle, the receptacle accommodating a coreless roll of toilet tissue, as required by claim 10. The toilet paper roll cover concealer and holder of Hertz (Figure 4) may fairly be viewed as a non-rotatable receptacle for a paper roll, with the receptacle having depressible pin projections 14 (Figure 6) to be sprung into openings 12, 13 within a wall recess 11 (Figure 3). Simply stated, it is the view of this panel of the board that a collective evaluation of the respective teachings of Avery and Hertz would not have provided a sound basis for one having ordinary skill in the art to so reconfigure the label dispenser of Avery as to address the particular features of the apparatus of claim 10 as set forth, supra, absent impermissible 6Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 NextLast modified: November 3, 2007