Ex parte OUCHI et al. - Page 4




          Appeal No. 97-1621                                                          
          Application 08/073,586                                                      


               Suarez also discloses an apparatus for separating tubing               
          into predetermined lengths.  As described by Suarez,                        
               [t]he apparatus includes drive rollers to feed the                     
               workpiece, horizontal and vertical straightener                        
               rollers, and a movable carriage assembly which moves in                
               a parallel path of travel to the workpiece.  The free                  
               end of the workpiece contacts the carriage assembly and                
               imparts movement to the assembly.  The carriage                        
               assembly includes a cutter assembly for severing the                   
               workpiece, a stripper assembly for breaking the article                
               from the workpiece, and a kick-out for sending the                     
               article to a storage bin [Abstract].                                   
               Sato discloses a system for the continuous processing of an            
          elongate steel plate.  The system includes a central processing             
          unit having loopers positioned at its entrance and exit ends to             
          control the traveling speed of the plate.  Each of the loopers              
          consists of a plurality of fixed upper rollers and a plurality of           
          lower rollers mounted on a vertically adjustable carriage.                  
               Wallis discloses a machine for cutting tubing into                     
          predetermined lengths wherein cutting assemblies are reciprocated           
          longitudinally in synchronism with the tubing by a motor-driven             
          gear and crank assembly.                                                    
               With regard to the standing 35 U.S.C. § 103 rejection of               
          independent claim 1, the examiner finds that the apparatus                  
          disclosed by Stroup meets all of the limitations in this claim              
          except for those requiring a cutter blade mounted on a movable              
          stand and a stretcher having movable rollers (see page 9 in the             
                                         -4-                                          





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007