Ex parte WEINBERGER - Page 7




          Appeal No. 97-4173                                                          
          Application 08/575,963                                                      



          language of claim 1 requires, since each such symbol would                  
          constitute a coupon value located within a segment, the                     
          different symbols would be a plurality of different coupon                  
          values, and the number of aligned segments (of the same                     
          symbol) would “represent a total coupon value,” as recited.                 
                    Accordingly, the combination of Fukuda and Wilhelm                
          meets all the limitations of claim 1, and the rejection of                  
          that claim will be sustained.  Since appellant states that                  
          claim 3 stands or falls with claim 1 (brief, page 5), its                   
          rejection will likewise be sustained.                                       
                    As for claim 5, appellant further argues that                     
          neither Fukuda nor Wilhelm suggests adding the accumulated                  
          value of similar coupons on the aligned segments of the reels.              
          We agree.  Claim 5 requires adding the coupon values displayed              
          on the left reel to any similar coupon values located (in                   
          alignment) on the other two reels, with the total coupon value              
          being the sum of those values.  The examiner does not assert,               
          and we are not aware, that in the normal operation of a slot                
          machine the pay off is determined by adding up the values of                
          the aligned symbols.  There is therefore no suggestion from                 

                                          7                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007