Ex parte BRIGHT et al. - Page 7




          Appeal No. 98-1692                                                          
          Application No. 07/715,145                                                  


          dispute that the icon which is the subject of the claimed                   
          design is for use on a computer-related display.  The question              
          before us, however, is whether there was adequate support in                
          the original disclosure for that which is now claimed, i.e.,                
          the icon originally shown in the drawings surrounded by a                   
          broken line purporting to depict a computer display screen.                 
          We find nothing in either of the declarations that convinces                
          us that there was, indeed, adequate support in the application              
          as originally filed for that which is now claimed.                          
               As an additional reason for sustaining this rejection, we              
          note that the evidence indicates that at the time of filing                 
          the original application, appellants had no intention of                    
          disclosing or claiming a computer display with a merge icon,                
          but, rather, appellants were interested only in obtaining                   
          protection for the design of the icon, itself.  We note the                 
          title of the application, as filed, “ Merge Icon For a                      
          Computer Display Or The Like” [emphasis ours].  Thus, the                   
          display, itself, and/or the icon’s relationship with such                   
          display appears to have been of no interest to appellants.  It              
          was clearly the icon, itself, for use with or on a computer                 


                                          7                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007