Ex parte PLOG et al. - Page 2




           Appeal No. 95-0665                                                                  
           Application 08/082,326                                                              

           (Paper No. 28), contending that claims 6-8 are patentable over                      
           art.                                                                                
                In the request for reconsideration, the appellants point                       
           out                                                                                 
           that in column 26, lines 36-40 of Frieder, the reference to                         
           granting access to the main store on a "fixed priority basis"                       
           does not contemplate interrupting an already commenced but yet                      
           unfinished memory access to accommodate a higher priority                           
           memory access.  The appellants refer to column 27, lines 31-49                      
           of Frieder and state that once access to memory is granted                          
           based on the fixed priority scheme, the access is completely                        
           performed before the arbitration circuit is released for                            
           granting the next access to memory.                                                 
                The appellants have, evidently, misinterpreted our                             
           opinion. We did not express the view that Frieder itself                            
           discloses having a high priority memory access interrupt a low                      
           priority memory access in mid-stream.  Apparently, as pointed                       
           out by the appellants, it does not.  The rejection is one for                       
           obviousness under 35 U.S.C. § 103, not for anticipation under                       
           35 U.S.C.                                                                           
           § 102.                                                                              

                                               2                                               





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007