Ex parte NUCKOLLS - Page 4




          Appeal No. 96-0447                                                          
          Application No. 08/145,731                                                  

          circuit of claim 18 is “for operating,” not starting, an HID                
          lamp.  At line 12 of the claim, it is recited that an output                
          pulse is provided “in order to operate said lamp.”                          
          Accordingly, all of these claims are directed to the                        
          “operation circuit,” and not to the “starting circuit” for a                
          HID lamp.                                                                   


               Further, independent claims 12, 14, 15 and 18 all require              
          a “same order of magnitude” limitation.  Claim 12 recites that              
          the first voltage storing means and the second voltage storing              
          means are selected so that a value of the first energy level                
          is of the same order of magnitude as a value of the second                  
          energy level while claim 14 recites that the high energy loop               
          has an energy value of the same order of magnitude as, but                  
          greater than, an energy value of the low energy loop.  Claim                
          18 recites that the value of a first capacitor is the same                  
          order of magnitude as a value of a second capacitor.  Claim 15              
          recites that a value of each of at least two levels of energy               
          is of the same order of magnitude as a value of another one of              
          the two levels of energy.                                                   



                                          4                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007