Ex parte ONO - Page 6




          Appeal No. 96-3128                                                          
          Application 08/246,723                                                      



               Upon a careful review of Peppers, we fail to find that                 
          Peppers teaches "each of said plurality of said optical                     
          correlation operation means detects a respective portion of                 
          said optical pattern displayed by said input information                    
          displaying means" as recited in Appellant's claim 1.                        
          Furthermore, we note that claims 2 through 27 recite the above              
          limitations.  Column 1, lines 6-13, the portion of Peppers                  
          that the Examiner has directed our attention, is the stated                 
          field of invention.  However, this is not a teaching of a                   
          portion of the optical image being displayed is only received               
          by the optical correlation operation means.  Peppers teaches                
          in column 7, line 68, to column 8, line 9, that the input                   
          image formed on the screen of the display 1 is received by the              
          first lens of the array 3 and is multiplied by the image                    
          formation lenses 3a as shown in Figure 1.  Peppers further                  
          teaches that the optical pattern images 5a shown in Figures 3               
          through 5 are formed on imaginary image formation plane 5.                  
          Thus, the entire optical pattern is outputted to each                       
          correlation means 3a, 6a and 7a shown in Peppers' Figure 1.                 
          Therefore, we find that Peppers fails to teach all of the                   

                                          6                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007