Ex parte SETO et al. - Page 5




          Appeal No. 96-3200                                         Page 5           
          Application No. 08/337,196                                                  


          Watson specifies a plurality of virtual processors in sequence              
          of use.  However, as argued by appellants [brief-page 6], in                
          Watson, “not a plurality of sequences, as in the case of the                
          present invention, but only one sequence is stored...”                      
               Now, it may be, as apparently contended by the examiner,               
          that the peripheral processor 11 of Watson may be considered to             
          be the single microprocessor, as claimed, and the plurality of              
          virtual processors, which form a part of the peripheral                     
          processor, may be considered to be the claimed “program                     
          counters,” since Watson explains, at column 18, lines 25-27,                
          that the virtual processors comprise program counters.  One                 
          might even make the argument that these program counters are                
          “selected,” as claimed, because, at column 19, lines 34-37,                 
          Watson explains that the time available to one or more of the               
          virtual processors may be allocated.                                        
               But, even assuming all this to be true and applicable to               
          the instant claims, claims 12 and 22 each require, inter alia,              
          in one form or another, that one may designate the order in                 
          which each of the program counters is to be selected by the                 
          selecting means.  Claim 12 specifically recites “wherein a user             
          can designate said order...” [emphasis ours].  Clearly, there               







Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007