Ex parte CARMACK et al. - Page 4




          Appeal No. 96-3765                                                          
          Application No. 08/209,522                                                  


               to communicate via the inherent video display output                   
               and video display signals of Schultz (see, e.g.,                       
               inherent to the use of a CRT display screen in                         
               Schultz, col. 6, ll. 47-49) in order to increase the                   
               input/output capacity of Schultz because                               
               communicating via the video display output port and                    
               signals frees any existing input-output ports and                      
               parallel printer ports for other types of                              
               communications.                                                        
               The examiner assumes that Schultz's system inherently                  
          includes a video display output and video display signals.                  
          The phrase "video signal" generally is used in the context of               
          televisions and conventionally is defined at least as narrowly              
          as in the following dictionary definition presented by                      
          appellants (Brief, page 11): "The signal containing all of the              
          visual                                                                      
          information together with blanking and synchronizing pulses."               
          Schultz discloses (column 7, lines 25-28) a "word processor or              
          text source" for generating a document to be printed or                     
          displayed.  Displaying text data requires at least a standard               
          display signal, as that provided to a CRT, but not the                      
          synchronizing and blanking pulses of a video signal.  Since                 
          the examiner has pointed to nothing in the reference to                     
          indicate that Schultz even contemplated use of a video signal,              
          nor to any extrinsic evidence that Schultz actually includes                
                                          4                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007