Ex parte BRINLEY - Page 6




          Appeal No. 1997-0533                                                        
          Application No. 08/353,916                                                  


          patterned surface of the chilled roller 19 with the exposed                 
          surface of the polyethylene having a smooth configuration                   
          (column 4, lines 31-43).  In the process disclosed by                       
          Anderson, any metal foil used never comes in contact with the               
          surface of the chilled roller 19 (see Figure 3; column 3,                   
          lines 40-61).                                                               
               Brinley is directed to the same process as the claimed                 
          subject matter on appeal except that the polymer film 5 of                  
          Brinley is embossed while the claimed process embosses a metal              
          foil (compare Figure 1 of Brinley with the Figure of this                   
          application).  The examiner has not pointed to any disclosure               
          or suggestion of a metal foil in Brinley.  The process of                   
          Brinley forms sequential layers of paper, molten resin, and                 
          polymeric film, where the heat of the molten resin is                       
          transferred to the outer polymeric film to raise the film                   
          above its plastic set temperature, i.e., the temperature above              
          which an applied stress will cause permanent deformation of                 
          the film.  Therefore the exposed surface of the polymeric film              
          is able to assume the pattern of the engraved chill roll 7                  
          (column 4, lines 16-27).                                                    


                                          6                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007