Ex parte BLACKMON et al. - Page 7




            Appeal No. 97-2583                                                                          
            Application 08/156,951                                                                      

            which is shared by the host system and the control processor.                               
                  Our reading of Longo reveals that the host system and the                             
            control processor do not draw pictures on the same display at                               
            the same time.  In Longo’s column 12, lines 53-56, it is                                    
            stated:                                                                                     
                        There are two embodiments that allow both                                       
                  systems to access the screen 38 without destroying                                    
                  the previous screen contents once in operational                                      
                  mode i.e., loopback and control processor console                                     
                  emulation.                                                                            
                  In the loopback mode, no drawing is done directly by the                              
            control processor.  See column 12, lines 59-64.  Data for                                   
            display is passed from the control processor back to the host                               
            system.  Consequently, Longo states that in the loopback mode                               
            there is no need to arbitrate between the two bodies of                                     
            software having access to the single piece of hardware.                                     
            (Column 12, lines 64-66).  In the control processor emulation                               
            mode, it appears that the control processor would direct                                    
            display data to the screen through the rendering processor                                  
            while the host is evidently halted, as has been argued by the                               
            appellants.  See column 13, line 62 to column 14, line 17, and                              
            column 14, lines 58-64.                                                                     
                  In short, the examiner has not set forth a sufficient                                 

                                                   7                                                    





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007