Ex parte GARIBOLDI - Page 3




          Appeal No. 98-0494                                                          
          Application No. 07/954,056                                                  


                    The continuous surface between the toe and the                    
               waistband of the garment, except for the line portion in               
               the crotch area, results in an uninterrupted outer edge                
               (see Figures 9, 10 and 13 as well as the figures wherein               
               the article of the design takes the shape of a mannequin,              
               Figures 11, 12, 1).  Additionally, there is an                         
               uninterrupted, continuous inner edge from the toe line                 
               portion to the crotch line portion. . . .                              
                    Two alternate embodiments are proposed, according to              
               the invention, namely one wherein the leg portion is                   
               substantially tubular and of substantially constant                    
               dimension (in unstretched state; see for example, Figure               
               9) as well as the embodiment of Figure 10, wherein a line              
               as can be seen in Figure 6 is provided.  As can be seen in             
               Figure 10, the second embodiment provides a taper in the               
               leg region of the article whereas the embodiment of Figure             
               9 has tubular leg regions.  The thigh portion of the                   
               garment is wider than calf portion of the garment.  This               
               allows a person with larger thighs to wear the garment                 
               without unduly stretching the garment.  In the embodiment              
               of Figure 10 (also Figure 6), an additional widening                   
               stitch or line is provided to allow for the change in                  
               dimension (without stretching of the garment[)].                       
               Appellant argues that Harris, either alone or in combination           
          with Fillmore, fails to teach or suggest a pantyhose article having         
          an uninterrupted, continuous appearance as claimed (Brief, pp.4 and         
          11).  More specifically, appellant argues that the combination of           
          Harris and Fillmore fails to teach or suggest the overall appearance        
          of the claimed pantyhose article both in its stretched state as             
          illustrated in Figures 1, 11 and 12 and its unstretched state as            
          illustrated in Figures 9 and 10 (Brief, pp.5, 7-8 and 10-11).               


                                          3                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007