Ex parte DILLER - Page 4




                 Appeal No. 95-3698                                                                                       Page 4                        
                 Application No. 08/006,717                                                                                                             




                 does not persuade us that our decision was in error in any                                                                             
                 respect.  In that regard, the claimed "pivotal means" is recited                                                                       
                 as being disposed between the car body and the second carriage                                                                         
                 permitting free pivotal movement of the car body about a                                                                               
                 generally horizontal axis relative to the second carriage as                                                                           
                 said pin means sliding in the groove causes the car body to                                                                            
                 pivot about the generally horizontal axis relative to the first                                                                        
                 carriage.  However, the coupling heads disclosed in Figures 12-                                                                        
                 14 are disposed between a first freight car and a coupled rear                                                                         
                 freight car so that the first freight car can be tilted                                                                                
                 independently of the rear freight car as is the case when the                                                                          
                 first freight car is traversing a curve, while the rear freight                                                                        
                 car is still on a straight track (specification, p. 12, lines                                                                          
                 20-23).  Thus, the disclosed coupling heads are to couple                                                                              
                 together two different freight cars.  The claimed "pivotal                                                                             
                 means" is structure provided on a single car body  "disposed                            5                                              
                 between said car body and said second carriage."  Accordingly,                                                                         
                 the disclosed coupling heads are not structure that corresponds                                                                        


                          5Claim 27 recites "a first and second carriage underlying                                                                     
                 said car body."                                                                                                                        






Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007