Ex Parte IKEDA et al - Page 7




               Appeal No. 1997-2947                                                                                                 
               Application No. 08/352,079                                                                                           


                       Abe provides several examples of the catalytic converter.  For instance, Example 1                           
               describes the formation of an adsorbent heater where a honeycomb structure is coated with                            
               adsorbent zeolite.  This adsorbent heater was then placed in front of a monolith catalyst which                      
               was a commercially available three-way catalyst supported on a ceramic honeycomb structure.                          
               (Example 1).  Additionally, while not explicitly stated, a zeolite adsorbent was present in                          
               Example 1 which was then replaced in Example 3 by a zeolite adsorbent-catalyst composition.                          
               (Examples 1 and 3).  In Example 3 the zeolite adsorbent-catalyst was composed of zeolite,                            
               platinum and rhodium on a honeycomb carrier formed with Al2O3CeO2.2  (Example 3).  In yet                            
               another example, the three-way catalyst of Examples 1 and 3 was provided upstream from the                           
               adsorbent-catalyst.  (Example 5).  Additionally, Examples 11 and 12 depict a catalytic converter                     
               where the three-way catalyst is placed upstream from the zeolite adsorbent-catalyst and heater.                      
               (Table 2, Examples 11 and 12).                                                                                       


                                                       Claim Construction                                                           
                       In order to determine the patentability of the claims, we must first construe the meaning                    
               of the claims.  In interpreting the claim language, we look first to the intrinsic evidence of record,               
               i.e., the application itself, including the claims, the specification and the prosecution history.                   
               Within this intrinsic evidence, the appropriate starting point is always the language of the claims                  


                       2 CeO2 is also known as ceric oxide or ceria.  Al2O3 is also known as aluminum oxide or                      
               alumina.                                                                                                             
                                                                 7                                                                  





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007