Ex parte COBB et al. - Page 6




          Appeal No. 1997-3429                                                        
          Application 08/307,212                                                      

          (emphasis added).  That is, when the subordinate is                         
          coordinating "read-only" resources (resources that are not                  
          modifiable by a transaction), there is no dynamic                           
          registration and no message should be sent in response to                   
          the "Prepare" message to cause registration.                                
               Once the subordinate in Lampson is registered as                       
          "read-only," no "commit" or "abort" message is sent to that                 
          subordinate.  This is contrary to the limitation of "sending                
          a [sic] transaction messages from superior coordinators only                
          to registered, directly subordinate coordinators, thereby                   
          reducing message traffic" because the "read-only"                           
          subordinate has registered according to the Examiner's                      
          interpretation and yet is not sent any messages.  While the                 
          result in Lampson is similar to the disclosed invention in                  
          that "read-only" subordinates are not sent certain messages,                
          the claimed protocol is different.  There is no need for the                
          coordinator to keep track of "read-only" subordinates in the                
          claimed method because "read-only" subordinates are never                   
          registered.                                                                 





                                        - 6 -                                         





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007