Ex parte TIPTON et al. - Page 5




          Appeal No. 1998-0578                                                         
          Application 08/349,633                                                       

          hazardous materials, (2) materials identified by the trade                   
          names of the hazardous materials, (3) a preset mixture of                    
          hazardous materials, or (4) a variable mixture of hazardous                  
          materials.  Claim 21 specifies that the classification enables               
          “such system to track each container of hazardous material in                
          any one of said designations from its beginning as an in-use                 
          hazardous material through its disposal as a waste hazardous                 
          material.”                                                                   
               The key to this appeal centers around the claimed                       
          recitation of “first data representing containers storing                    
          hazardous materials that are in-use (emphasis added).”  The                  
          appellant’s specification in lines 21-23 on page 54 defines                  
          the term as follows:  “As stated above, the term in-use is                   
          used to define a group of chemical containers that are                       
          maintained in inventory and are presently being used”                        
          (emphasis added).  In contrast, the specification in lines 11-               
          14 on the same page defines “waste” as “a grouping of chemical               
          containers of chemical stock waiting to be disposed of and                   
          removed from the inventory systems.”  It is manifestly clear                 
          that in light of the appellants’ specification, hazardous                    



                                          5                                            





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007