Ex parte EASON et al. - Page 5




              Appeal No. 1998-1258                                                                 Page 5                 
              Application No. 08/442,676                                                                                  


                     Boyhan is directed to an apparatus and method for packaging discrete articles                        
              such as pieces of candy into an apertured container.  As explained with regard to Figures                   
              1-I through 1-IV, this is accomplished by placing first pieces to be packaged into first                    
              cavities (14) in a first plate member (10) and second pieces to be packaged in second                       
              cavities (20) in a second plate (16).  The first and second cavities are not aligned with one               
              another, but the first cavities are aligned with openings (22) in the second plate which are                
              interposed between the second cavities.  In order to load the package, the second plate is                  
              oriented over the first plate and the package is placed upside down over the second plate,                  
              as shown in Figure 1-III, whereupon all three components are inverted, causing the second                   
              pieces to fall directly into cavities in the package and the first pieces to fall through the               
              apertures in the second plate member into others of the cavities in the package.  Thus, the                 
              motivating force for loading the articles is the influence of gravity.  Boyhan is not concerned             
              with loading apertures with particulate material, but with discrete articles, so the problems               
              to which the appellants’ method is concerned are not recognized.   In addition, from our                    
              perspective, Boyhan fails to disclose or teach using a porous member that will allow the                    
              passage of gas but prevent the passage of the material being loaded, as well as loading                     
              the material by means of gas pressure.                                                                      
                     Ulveling is concerned with injecting powdered coal into a furnace.  This is                          
              accomplished by alternately loading a pair of intermediate silos (24A and 24B) by                           









Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007