Ex parte HOOD - Page 5




          Appeal No. 1999-2788                                                        
          Application No. 08/910,469                                                  


          disclose a pointed tip at an outermost distal end of the blade              
          body, as set forth in independent claim 1 on appeal.  The                   
          language of independent claim 1 relating to the recessed                    
          cutting portion terminating in a pointed tip "at an outermost               
          distal end of said body" was first added to claim 1 in an                   
          amendment filed May 12, 1997 in the parent of the present                   
          application.  Appellant's specification does not use the same               
          language as claim 1 in describing the recessed portion (22)                 
          and the pointed tip (24) of the cutting blade (12). More                    
          specifically, the specification does not mention or describe                
          "an outermost distal end of said body," as is set forth in                  
          claim 1 on appeal.  Therefore, our principal guidance for                   
          understanding this language must come from appellant's                      
          drawings.                                                                   


          Figure 1 of appellant's drawings shows the cutting blade                    
          body (20) as terminating in an outermost distal end that is                 
          contoured or curved from its upper or second side to its lower              
          or first side and which terminates at the first side at a                   
          pointed tip (24).  Thus, as is apparent from Figure 1, the                  
          entirety of the curved or contoured surface at the end of the               
                                          5                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007