Ex parte AULT et al. - Page 6




          Appeal No. 2000-1360                                                        
          Application No. 08/632,251                                                  


          the resource if both the client and the server are                          
          independently allowed the access to the resource.  If not,                  
          access to the resource is denied.                                           
               Thus, access to a resource is granted only if both the                 
          client and the server are independently allowed access to the               
          resource.                                                                   
               We do not find this limitation taught or suggested by the              
          applied references.  The examiner contends otherwise, stating               
          that Baker’s proxy server 112 has independently specified                   
          rights to the host resources 101-105.  The examiner quotes,                 
          “...retrieves rating and rational information from resource                 
          categorization information listing 300, and provides a manager              


          with a page that facilitates editing of the rating,” citing                 
          Figure 6 and column 7, lines 40-43, and concluding that this                
          “implies that the server having independently specified access              
          rights (user clearance and resource rating) to the host                     
          resource (network resource)” [answer-pages 10-11].                          
               We are at a loss to understand how the examiner is                     
          interpreting Baker to arrive at the claimed limitation of the               
          independently allowed access to the resource by the client and              
          the server.  Rather, we agree with appellants that Baker’s                  
                                         6–                                           



Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007