Ex parte RIEKKINEN et al. - Page 5




          Appeal No. 2001-0558                                                        
          Application No. 08/966,708                                                  

          prior art does not respond to the limitations in independent                
          claim 32 relating to the bonding strip.                                     
               Witty discloses a self-contained reagent package and                   
          calibration assembly comprising a plurality of reagent package              
          devices 10 and a reagent standards device 50.  Each reagent                 
          package device includes a plurality of wells with open top                  
          ends and a removable protective cover 21 sealed to the top of               
          the package to close the open top ends of all but one of the                
          wells.  The reagent standards device includes a plurality of                
          receptacles having open top ends and a removable protective                 
          cover 60 substantially similar to the removable cover 21 for                
          closing these open top ends.                                                
               In proposing to combine the admitted prior art and Witty               
          to reject claim 32, the examiner submits that                               
               Witty et al suggest providing a strip of bonding                       
               material 60 over a plurality of test tubes 68 to                       
               seal the respective openings to protect the test                       
               cells from contamination and provide a surface for                     
               labeling information.  Therefore, it would have been                   
               obvious in view of Witty et al to provide a strip of                   
               protective material to cover the openings of the                       
               cuvettes of the Admitted Prior Art and to assemble                     
               them into one package for shipping.  One of ordinary                   
               skill in the    . . . art would readily understand                     
               the width of the strip can be decreased as long as                     
               the strip covers the openings of the cuvettes and                      
               would have found it obvious to alter the width of                      
               the strip to anything less than the width of the                       
                                          5                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007