Ex parte STYCZINSKI - Page 8




          Appeal No. 1998-1517                                        Page 8           
          Application No. 08/685,269                                                   


          equal storage capacity with the exception that disk 0 has                    
          slightly less storage capacity.  Jacobson further discloses                  
          (col. 5, lines 8-16) that                                                    
               [T]he RAID management system effectively "tunes" the                    
               storage resources of a memory system according to the                   
                    application or user requirements.  For instance, in                
          an                                                                           
               application requiring high performance and reliability,                 
               the RAID management system may create and define a                      
               proportionally larger mirror RAID area, thereby                         
               dedicating a larger amount of physical storage capacity                 
               to mirror redundancy, in comparison to the parity RAID                  
               area.                                                                   

          Moreover, in Jacobson (col. 7, lines 44-53), RAID management                 
          system 16 selectively adjusts the memory allocation between                  
          parity and mirror areas according to the specific performance                
          and reliability requirements of the various applications.                    
               From our review of Jacobson, we find no teaching or                     
          suggestion of providing a single predefined mirror drive for a               
          plurality of data drives with the single predefined mirror                   
          drive provided with a set capacity substantially greater that                
          the capacity of each of the plurality of data drives, as                     
          recited in claim 1.                                                          
               We do not agree with the examiner (answer, pages 4 and 8)               
          that providing a single predefined mirror drive with a set                   







Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007