Ex parte UNRATH et al. - Page 8




          Appeal No. 1999-1332                                                        
          Application No. 08/591,857                                                  



          frame side plates 58 and 60 adhesively attached thereto                     
          (column 4, lines 6-9) is then immersed in the adhesive 48 and               
          when the adhesive hardens, the tapes are removed, leaving the               
          pleated edge of the filter core encapsulated in the adhesive                
          and the end plate 24 secured to the core subassembly (column                
          4, lines 24-28).  The unit is then inverted and end plate 66                
          is secured to the core subassembly in the same manner (column               
          4, lines 28-36).  In the completed air filter, the notched                  
          ends of the side plates 58 and 60 receive the strips of the                 
          end plates (column 4, lines 15-20; Figure 5).                               
               Lippold, the tertiary reference in each of the                         
          rejections, is mentioned in appellants’ specification (page 7,              
          lines 17-18) and is representative of the type of                           
          dimensionally stable filter pack that may be used in the                    
          practice of the present invention.  Lippold contains no                     
          details concerning the frame of a cassette filter utilizing                 
          the filter pack disclosed therein.                                          
               Considering first the standing rejection of claim 1, the               
          examiner concedes (answer, page 4) that Allan does not meet                 
          the requirements of the third paragraph of claim 1 regarding                

                                          8                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007