Ex parte FAJOUR - Page 11




          Appeal No. 1999-1629                                                         
          Application 08/510,491                                                       

          . . ." (claim 1) does not preclude operating "said set of said               
          nozzles" as well the "other of said nozzles"; i.e., it does                  
          not require operating only the other nozzles as argued.                      
          Claim 1 does not preclude the use of a counter as a condition                
          for the controller to cause non-used nozzles to eject ink in                 
          addition to the condition that there is no mail item in front                
          of the print head.  While Appellant's invention does not                     
          require a counter if the nozzles are purged after every                      
          franking cycle (specification, p. 7, lines 29-32), it would                  
          require a counter if the nozzles were purged every ten                       
          franking cycles (specification, p. 8, line 7).  Thus, a                      
          counter is not inconsistent with the disclosed invention.  It                
          is also noted that the limitation of "a reservoir disposed                   
          below the print head at said print position into which said                  
          ink is ejected by said other of said nozzles" (claim 1) does                 
          not preclude the reservoir from capturing ink from all                       
          nozzles, although it is disclosed that the reservoir can be                  
          small and compact because it only has to collect ink purged                  
          from the nozzles not used for printing (specification, p. 7,                 
          lines 16-20).                                                                



                                        - 11 -                                         





Page:  Previous  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007