Ex Parte SANSONE - Page 3




            Appeal No. 2000-0376                                                                         
            Application 08/753,236                                                                       

                  Claim 1 is reproduced below.                                                           
                        1.  An improved metering system that affixes an indicia                          
                  to a mail piece, the improvement comprising: recording                                 
                  information relative to printing parameters of a printer                               
                  that recorded the indicia on the mail piece, wherein the                               
                  recorded information is recorded in the indicia or in the                              
                  vicinity of the indicia to provide evidence of the printer                             
                  printing parameters used to record the indicia.                                        

                                            THE PRIOR ART                                                
                  The Examiner relies on the following references:                                       
                  Chapman, Jr. (Chapman)               4,106,060      August 8, 1978                     
                  Kipphan et al. (Kipphan)             4,955,290  September 11, 1990                     
                  Bruns et al. (Bruns)                 5,005,995       April 9, 1991                     
                  Johnsen                              5,151,684  September 29, 1992                     
                  Dietrich                             5,186,498   February 16, 1993                     
                  Kim et al. (Kim)                     5,480,239     January 2, 1996                     
                  Billington                           5,489,767    February 6, 1996                     
                  Morrison et al. (Morrison)           5,543,177      August 6, 1996                     
                  Smaha et al. (Smaha)                 5,557,742  September 17, 1996                     
                  Cordery et al. (Cordery)             5,655,023      August 5, 1997                     
            (filed May 13, 1994)                                                                         
                  Zabele                               5,712,921    January 27, 1998                     
            (filed November 17, 1995)                                                                    
                  Mizutani                             5,774,146       June 30, 1998                     
            (filed August 30, 1996)                                                                      
                  Schwartz et al. (Schwartz)           5,780,778       July 14, 1998                     
            (filed June 7, 1995)                                                                         
                  Information Based Indicia Program Postal Security Device                               
                  Specification, prepared for United States Postal Service                               
                  (USPS) Engineering Center (June 13, 1996) (hereinafter                                 
                  Information Based Indicia Program or IBIP).                                            

                  The main reference to Dietrich is summarized below.                                    
                  Dietrich disclose a method of identifying a postage meter                              
            and monetary value stamping machine, which uses microprocessor-                              
            controlled printing methods, such as laser printing, dot matrix                              

                                                 - 3 -                                                   





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007