Ex Parte BENAZZI et al - Page 2




           Appeal No. 2001-0771                                                                      
           Application No. 09/103,528                                                                

           pursuant to the provisions of 37 CFR § 1.142(b), as being drawn                           
           to a nonelected invention and, thus, are not before us.                                   
                 The claims before us are directed to an EU-1 zeolite                                
           (hereinafter referred to as EU-1), defined in “product-by-                                
           process” terms, as well as a process for modifying EU-1 by                                
           removing at least some of element “T,” e.g., aluminum, from a                             
           starting zeolite.                                                                         
                 Appellants request separate consideration of claims 3-6.                            
           Therefore, all the other claims on appeal stand or fall with                              
           claim 1, the sole independent claim.  Accordingly, we focus our                           
           attention primarily upon claim 1 which reads as follows:                                  
                 1.  A modified EU-1 zeolite comprising silicon and an                               
                 element T which is Al, Fe, Ga, or B, produced by a process                          
                 in which at least a portion of elements T are removed from a                        
                 starting zeolite, whereby the modified zeolite has a global                         
                 atomic ratio Si/T higher than that of the starting zeolite,                         
                 by at least 10% of the Si/T ratio of the starting zeolite.                          
                 The prior art references relied upon by the examiner on                             
           appeal are:                                                                               
           Casci et al. (Casci)           4,537,754           Aug. 27, 1985                          
           Kuehl et al. (Kuehl)           4,954,243           Sep.  4, 1990                          






                                                 2                                                   





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007