Ex Parte CONZELMANN et al - Page 4




             Appeal No. 2001-1210                                                               Page 4                
             Application No. 09/255,990                                                                               


             Claim 1                                                                                                  
                    We sustain the rejection of claim 1 under 35 U.S.C. § 103.                                        


                    Claim 1 reads as follows:                                                                         
                           A method for two-sided printing of a sheet of printing material having a                   
                    front side and a rear side, in a sheet-fed rotary printing press, which comprises:                
                           cleaning the front side of a sheet of printing material before printed [sic,               
                    printing] thereon in a sheet-fed rotary printing press;                                           
                           also cleaning the rear side of the sheet before printing thereon in a sheet-               
                    fed rotary printing press.                                                                        


                    Wood discloses a web-treating device for printing-presses.  Specifically, Wood                    
             teaches the benefits of cleaning both surfaces of a web prior to printing on the web.  As                
             shown in Figure 1, the cleaning device is disposed upstream of a web-fed rotary                          
             printing press (impression cylinders A and C and printing cylinders B and D) which                       
             prints on both sides of the web.  The cleaning device cleans both sides of the web and                   
             includes rotating brushes 13 and 17.                                                                     


                    Grindley's invention relates to improvements in apparatus for removing dusting                    
             powder or residue particles from paper sheets during movement of the sheets in a                         
             printing press, and prior to the printing (or reprinting) thereof.  Grindley teaches (column             
             1, lines 8-47) that                                                                                      








Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007