Ex Parte AHN - Page 6




          Appeal No. 2001-1982                                                        
          Application 08/892,716                                                      

          mounted, there will not be a snug fit between the housing and the           
          CRT, which allows foreign substances such as dust to enter the              
          monitor through the gap between the CRT and the seating surface.            
          Thus, the APA discloses that gate landings are formed on a CRT              
          seating surface of a housing and that such flash protrusions at             
          the gate landings cause the problem that the seating surface does           
          not fit snugly with the CRT.  The APA discloses that the problem            
          of fit is eliminated by grinding back the protrusion, which                 
          requires an extra step in the manufacturing process.                        
               Arai discloses, in connection with figures 40 and 41                   
          (col. 23, lines 14-30):                                                     
               [U]pon molding, a groove portion 115A which is recessed                
               inside is formed in a surface of a portion of a molded                 
               article 38A which is contiguous to the gate 39 of the hot              
               runner 40. . . .  Since a gate slug 39A formed in the                  
               gate 39 of the hot runner 40 will not project upward above a           
               surface 38A-2 of the molded article, the mating article can            
               be abutted with each other by surface contact.                         
          The motivation for recessing the gate landing and gate slug is              
          stated in the last sentence: so that a mating surface can be                
          abutted by surface contact.  Arai further discloses that the                
          product can be a CRT or any product made by injection molding               
          (col. 26, lines 34-39).                                                     
               With respect to independent claims 1, 2, and 6, the APA does           
          not teach the gate landing being recessed to a depth for fully              
          recessing the gate flash to avoid interference between the gate             


                                        - 6 -                                         





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007