Ex Parte OSTWALD et al - Page 2



          Appeal No. 2001-2664                                                        
          Application 09/354,814                                                      

          The system includes at least one transport robot operative to               
          move along a guide structure between the libraries.                         
               Reference is made to the appealed claims appended to                   
          appellant’s brief for further details with respect to the claimed           
          subject matter.                                                             
               The reference of record relied upon by the examiner as                 
          evidence of anticipation is:                                                
               Moy et al. (Moy)         4,928,245           May 22, 1990              
                                      REJECTION                                       
               Claims 1 through 28 and 30 through 33 stand rejected under             
          35 U.S.C. § 102 as anticipated by Moy.                                      
               According to appellant claims 1 through 28 and 30 through 33           
          stand or fall together.  Accordingly, we will limit our                     
          consideration to independent claim 1 on appeal.                             
                                    OPINION                                           
               We have carefully reviewed the claimed subject matter in               
          light of the arguments of the appellants and the examiner.  As a            
          result of this review, we have reached the finding that the                 
          claims on appeal lack novelty over the applied prior art.                   
          Accordingly, the rejection of the claims on appeal is affirmed.             
          Our reasons follow.                                                         

                                          -2-                                         




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007