Ex Parte MURPHY et al - Page 5



                    Appeal No. 2002-0484                                                                                                                                  
                    Application No. 09/274,617                                                                                                                            

                              Juhasz discloses a monitoring and recording system for                                                                                      
                    vehicles in which the jurisdiction is manually set by the                                                                                             
                    operator and the fuel values for a respective jurisdiction are                                                                                        
                    recorded in a tape drive.  The fuel values in the Juhasz system                                                                                       
                    come from a flow meter 10 placed in the fuel line.  Here again,                                                                                       
                    the values do not come from the engine control computer that                                                                                          
                    actually determines the amount of fuel to be delivered to the                                                                                         
                    fuel system.                                                                                                                                          
                              Consequently, neither reference relied upon by the examiner                                                                                 
                    in rejecting the independent claims on appeal discloses a means                                                                                       
                    or an engine control computer that sends fueling signals to an                                                                                        
                    engine fuel system and sends fuel values to be recorded.                                                                                              
                    Therefore, the combined teachings of these references do not                                                                                          
                    render the claimed subject matter prima facie obvious.                                                                                                
                              We have carefully reviewed the other applied references,                                                                                    
                    but find therein no teaching or suggestion for appellants'                                                                                            
                    claimed control system.  Accordingly, the rejections of all                                                                                           
                    claims on appeal are reversed.                                                                                                                        





                                                                                    55                                                                                    




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007