Ex Parte Schluger - Page 2




              Appeal No. 2002-0950                                                                 Page 2                
              Application No. 09/655,147                                                                                 


                            1.  A rectangular shaped sealed mail envelope of cardboard                                   
                            construction material characterized by presenting a miter                                    
                            joint appearance at each of four corners thereof comprising                                  
                                   a rectangular rear panel delimiting a selected width                                  
                            between opposite left and right side edges and having top                                    
                            and bottom edges,                                                                            
                                   left and right flaps respectively wholly joined from a                                
                            top to a bottom location of one said left and right edge of                                  
                            said rear panel and having operative positions folded upon                                   
                            said rear panel, each said left and right flap having top and                                
                            bottom inclined edges oriented in a converging relation to                                   
                            each other starting from a said top and bottom location and                                  
                            terminating at a clearance location therefrom,                                               
                                   a bottom panel and top panel respectively joined to                                   
                            said top and bottom edges of said rear panel and having                                      
                            operative positions folded upon and adhesively secured to                                    
                            said left and a1 said right flap in said underlying operative                                
                            positions interposed between said rear panel and said top                                    
                            and bottom panels, and2 a selected width size delimited                                      
                            between opposite sides of said top and bottom panels of an                                   
                            extent less than said width size3 of said rear panel and also                                
                            of an extent less than distances between length portions of                                  
                            said left and right flap top and bottom inclined edges so as                                 
                            to leave exposed a beginning length portion of said inclined                                 
                            edges of said opposite top and bottom edges of said left and                                 
                            right flaps,                                                                                 
                                   said top and bottom panels having opposite side                                       
                            inclined edges oriented in a converging relation to each                                     
                            other and aligning in parallel relation to each said exposed                                 
                            beginning length portion of said inclined edges of said left                                 
                            and right flaps and bounding a clearance therebetween,                                       
                            whereby said aligned edges in said parallel relation and said                                


                     1 As only one right flap has been recited in the claim, “a” is inappropriate and should be deleted. 
                     2 Insertion of language such as “said top and bottom panels each having” before “a selected width   
              size” would greatly improve the clarity and readability of the claim.                                      
                     3 The term “width size” lacks strict antecedent basis, in that a width, but not a width size, of the
              rear panel has been recited in the claim.  While this informality does not render the scope of the claim   
              indefinite, correction to maintain consistent terminology should be considered.                            





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007