Ex Parte GREEN - Page 6





                 who was employed at US Surgical. US Surgical sold staplers                          
                 for use in medical procedures.                                                      
                       18. 1 have attached a true and correct copy of another                        
                 entry from my 1995 notebook as Wang Exhibit 2036. The entry                         
                 "Earlier mtg with Leon Hirsch" is a note relating to a phone                        
                 conversation I had with Mr. Hirsch who was chairman and                             
                 chief executive officer of US Surgical.                                             
                       19. Upon reviewing this notebook entry I recall                               
                 discussing with Mr. Hirsch whether US Surgical would be                             
                 interested in a partnership to develop a system where a                             
                 stapler was attached to the system disclosed in the ATP                             
                 proposal.                                                                           
                       20. CMI continued to discuss a partnership with US                            
                 Surgical through 1997 as described in letters to Joe Devivo                         
                 and Jeff White dated May 23, 1997 and December 18, 1997,                            
                 respectively, true and correct copies are attached as Wang                          
                 Exhibits 2037 and 2038.                                                             
                       21. The letter to Mr. Devivo describes a partnership                          
                 to integrate the ZEUS with a One-Shot product provided by US                        
                 Surgical. ZEUS is a CMI product that includes a robotic                             
                 arm, a coupler pivotally attached to the arm, an endoscopic                         
                 instrument held by the coupler, and a controller. The                               
                 controller has a handle and is in electrical communication                          
                 with the robot arm so that movement of the controller                               
                 produces a proportional movement of the arm. The One-Shot                           
                 product sold by US Surgical was a stapler instrument.                               
                 The events that occurred as described in paragraphs 20 and                          
           21 of Dr. Wang's declaration are after the -critical date" of 7                           
           June 1995. Therefore, those events do not demonstrate a prior                             
           conception.                                                                               
                 In paragraph 17 of its declaration, Dr. Wang discusses an                           
           entry made in his notebook (Wang Ex. 2035) regarding a phone                              
           conversation he had with Mr. White of US Surgical on 12 January                           
           1995, and states that US Surgical sold staplers for use in                                
           medical procedures. Dr. Wang's statement that US Surgical sold                            

                                                - 6 -                                                







Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007