Ex parte PROLE et al. - Page 7




          Appeal No. 1999-1134                                                        
          Serial No. 08/334,465                                                       

          afforded by specific structure disposed in the openings of the              
          turns of the coolant passages, and only Appellants evidence                 
          that need.                                                                  
               In response to the Examiner's reliance  on Kaminski to8                                
          teach that rotor windings have "hot spots" and curing that                  
          problem by "adjusting the cooling scheme", Appellants point                 
          out that Kaminski deals with longitudinal grooves milled into               
          end windings, and not rotor body radial ducts as claimed.                   
          Appellants                                                                  
          assert that the cooling scheme for the end turns in Kaminski                
          has                                                                         




          no applicability to the windings within the rotor not forming               
          part of the end turns.                                                      
               The Examiner contends  that one of ordinary skill in the9                                                 
          art would know from the background of the invention section of              
          Kaminski that the cooling of rotor windings is often                        
          difficult, and that rotor windings with long ducts produce                  

               8Answer, page 6                                                        
               Answer, page 6.9                                                                     
                                          7                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007