Ex Parte HECKEL et al - Page 4



          Appeal No. 1999-2601                                                         
          Application 08/862,682                                                       

                                     DISCUSSION                                        
               The appellants’ specification indicates that the process set            
          forth in the appealed claims is designed to produce fiber-                   
          reinforced composite materials made of thermoplastics having high            
          molecular weight, which thermoplastics characteristically have               
          high melt viscosity.  According to the appellants, “[h]igh                   
          molecular weight improves recycling behavior because repeated                
          melting results in a melt which, despite its oxidative and                   
          thermal degradation, is still in the high-molecular-weight                   
          region” (specification, page 2).  In discussing the background               
          art (see pages 1 through 4 in the specification), the appellants             
          note that the use of highly viscous thermoplastics in the subject            
          environment is problematic for reasons such as inadequate wetting            
          of the fibers and low impregnation speeds.  Regarding the                    
          asserted capacity of their invention to overcome these problems,             
          the appellants explain that                                                  
               [i]t is surprising that such a good wetting of the                      
               fiber material, which was not believed to be possible,                  
               can be achieved at all using melts of high viscosity.                   
               It is particularly surprising that this effect is                       
               achieved at impregnation speeds which are substantially                 
               higher than those of EP 056703 for material of low                      
               viscosity.                                                              
               The principle underlying the invention is still                         
               unclear.  Perhaps, as a result of the increased                         
               tension, the drag flow accompanying the filaments leads                 
               to the formation, in the vicinity of the curvatures of                  
                                           4                                           



Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007