Ex Parte BICKERTON et al - Page 6




          Appeal No. 2001-0024                                                        
          Application No. 08/827,285                                 Page 6           


          (final rejection, page 4) that Bigus fails to disclose objects              
          that contain business financial data and perform general ledger             
          operations.  The examiner additionally asserts (id.) that Bigus             
          fails to disclose object classes that include an analysis group,            
          an account type group, and other account attributes used in                 
          ledger account maintenance.                                                 
               To overcome these deficiencies of Bigus, the examiner turns            
          to Marks for a teaching of a computer program that performs                 
          various record keeping functions.  The examiner asserts (id.)               
          that it would have been obvious to combine Marks’                           
          automated ledger account maintenance system with the teachings of           
          Bigus' object oriented data mining system for the purpose of                
          creating financial related application programs, such as general            
          ledge software, that are much easier for an application program             
          developer to update and maintain.  The examiner further relies              
          upon Marks for a teaching of a computer program that performs               
          various record keeping functions found in a business.  The                  
          examiner additionally relies upon Marks for a teaching of a                 
          computer program for record keeping procedures that uses system             
          accounting controls definable by the record keeping entity whose            
          accounts are dynamically maintained by the system.                          


                                                                                     





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007