Ex Parte KLINGER et al - Page 17


                    Appeal No. 2001-0407                                                                     Page 17                        
                    Application No. 08/460,215                                                                                              

                    composition for treating cyst formation associated with APKD, said composition                                          
                    comprising an isolated PKD1 gene having the DNA sequence of SEQ ID NO:1,                                                
                    its complement, or fragments thereof, and a pharmaceutically acceptable carrier                                         
                    or diluent.”  As discussed above, the intended use language in claim 45 does not                                        
                    limit the scope of the claimed composition.                                                                             
                            On return of this application, the examiner should consider whether the                                         
                    composition of instant claims 45-47 is the same as, or is not patentably distinct                                       
                    from, the compositions claimed in the ‘717 patent.  If the composition is the same                                      
                    or is not patentably distinct, a rejection for statutory or obviousness-type double                                     
                    patenting would be appropriate.                                                                                         




























Page:  Previous  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007