Ex Parte LEE et al - Page 23




          Appeal No. 2001-0740                                                        
          Application 09/054,415                                                      

          current from one current source when power requirements are                 
          relatively low and to provide a higher current from two current             
          sources when power requirements are relatively high.  The                   
          rejection of claim 10 is sustained.                                         

               Claim 11                                                               
               The examiner reads the "first current source" on current               
          sources 34, 41 in Fig. 2; the "first active device" on FET 47;              
          the "second active device" on MOSFET 46; the "second constant               
          current source" on MOSFETs 29, 36; and the "third active device"            
          on MOSFET 38, so that the gates of 38 and 46 are connected                  
          together, and the "active device having a gate terminal connected           
          to the junction of said second current source and said third                
          active device and controlled thereby" on MOSFETs 50, 51 (FR10).             
               Appellants' asserts that "claim 11 is a fairly detailed                
          claim, as discussed above, and Wang has no corresponding                    
          structure" (Br14).  Appellants previously correlated the                    
          limitations of claim 11 to Fig. 7 (Br9).                                    
               The examiner repeats his position (EA17-18).                           
               It appears that the elements pointed out by the examiner               
          satisfy the very broad claim language.  Appellants have not shown           
          any error in the examiner's findings.  Accordingly, the rejection           
          of claim 11 is sustained.                                                   

               Claim 12                                                               

                                       - 23 -                                         





Page:  Previous  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  28  29  30  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007