Ex Parte TANG - Page 5



          Appeal No. 2001-2029                                                         
          Application No. 09/095,170                                                   

          whether there is a strong signal at particular locations so that             
          this information may be used in order to generate a handover                 
          neighbor list, listing potential handover candidate base                     
          transceiver stations, this is not a method for locating a mobile             
          telephone within a communications network, as claimed.  The                  
          mobile telephone location does not need to be determined in Bonta            
          because it is already known.  Bonta is interested in using                   
          simulation apparatus, which may be a software simulation tool, to            
          utilize various handover parameters as well as predefined routes             
          and locations along which a mobile communication unit may travel,            
          to select the best possible target base transceiver stations for             
          a handover of a mobile communication signal from a source base               
          transceiver station to a target base transceiver station.  It is             
          true that Bonta partitions the system into a grid pattern and                
          assigns coordinates, which has some semblance to the claimed                 
          “plurality of sections using a set of substantially rectangular              
          grids.”  However, these grids are not used in the same manner                
          claimed in order to locate a mobile telephone within the network.            
               Moreover, appellant argues that Bonta does not disclose the             
          claimed “collecting location information and signal information              
          at each of said plurality of sections within said cell for                   
          signals transmitted by said base station and other base stations             
                                         -5-                                           




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007